As homebrewers, we're on a constant quest for the perfect pint. But sometimes, our brews throw us a curveball in the form of unexpected flavours. Let's dive into the chemistry behind these off-flavours and explore the technical aspects of how to avoid them.
The Cornerstones of Quality Brewing
Before we dissect off-flavours, let's revisit the fundamental principles of brewing excellence:
- Stringent sanitation protocols
- Proper yeast management and pitching rates
- Adequate wort oxygenation
- Precise fermentation temperature control
Now, let's examine the most common off-flavours from a more technical perspective.
Acetaldehyde: The Precursor Predicament
Acetaldehyde, usually a distinctive green or bruised apple aroma and flavour, is a natural byproduct of fermentation. This aldehyde is typically further converted to ethanol by the yeast. But under certain conditions, it can accumulate.
Prevention strategies:
- Ensure optimal dissolved oxygen levels (8-10 ppm) in wort pre-fermentation.
- Maintain an oxygen-free environment after fermentation has started.
- Raising the temperature of the fermentation towards the upper end of the yeast fermentation range. (also known as a diacetyl rest) helps to ensure a complete conversion to ethanol.
Diacetyl: The Vicinal Diketone Villain
Diacetyl, a vicinal diketone (VDK), imparts a buttery flavour and slick mouthfeel. It's produced as a byproduct of valine synthesis during fermentation and is usually reabsorbed by healthy yeast.
Mitigation techniques:
- Ensure an adequate amount of healthy yeast is pitched into the wort.
- Implement a proper diacetyl rest.
- Ensure adequate Free Amino Nitrogen (FAN) levels in the wort. Which can be done by adding yeast nutrients.
Esters: Balancing Fruity Fermentation Byproducts
Esters are formed through the esterification of organic acids and alcohols during fermentation. While some styles benefit from esters, particular esters and excessive levels can be undesirable in some styles.
Control methods:
- Manage fermentation temperatures within yeast-specific ranges.
- Calculate and implement proper pitching rates.
- Control wort composition, particularly Free Amino Nitrogen (FAN) levels.
Phenolics: Managing Polyphenol Production
Phenolic compounds can contribute spicy clove, burnt plastic or medicinal flavours. They can be produced by certain yeast strains or result from chlorophenol formation.
Avoidance strategies:
- Ensure high levels of sanitation are maintained.
- Water needs to be free of chlorine and chloramines. Carbon filtration or store-bought filter water can be used.
- Select appropriate yeast strains based on the desired flavour profile.
- Monitor mash pH to control polyphenol extraction from grain husks.
Fusel Alcohols: Higher Alcohol Havoc
Fusel alcohols, or higher alcohols, are formed by yeast during amino acid synthesis. Excessive levels can lead to harsh, solvent-like flavours.
Prevention methods:
- Maintain strict fermentation temperature control.
- Ensure proper wort aeration (8-10 ppm dissolved oxygen).
- Balance wort amino acid composition through nutrient addition.
Dimethyl Sulphide (DMS): Sulfur Compound Control
DMS, with its characteristic cooked corn aroma, but may also present as tinned tomatoes/ tomato sauce. Originates sulphur compounds in the malt and occurs through the break down of these compounds after the boil and through metabolisation during fermentation.
Reduction techniques:
- Implement a vigorous, rolling boil for at least 60 minutes.
- Rapid wort cooling to minimise DMS formation post-boil.
- Select malts with lower DMS precursors (Low S-Methyl Methionine (SMM)).
Acid Bacteria: Preventing Unwanted Sourness
Bacteria can produce sour flavours by producing lactic and acetic acids, which present as sourness or as vinegar notes at the back of the nose/ throat. Lactic acid and acetic acid are suitable for some styles of beer, but other bacteria can produce truly nasty acids like butyric acid, which smells like poopy nappie, which you wouldn't want in any beer.
Prevention strategies:
- Implement rigorous sanitation protocols with appropriate sanitisers.
- Maintain anaerobic (no oxygen) conditions during fermentation.
- Consider hop IBU for its antimicrobial properties.
Oxidation: Combating Oxygen Ingress
Oxidation can lead to a range of off-flavours, from cardboard-like to overly sweet notes, due to the formation of various compounds, including trans-2-nominal.
Mitigation methods:
- Minimise oxygen exposure post-fermentation through closed transfers
- Utilise CO2 purging techniques for kegs, bottles, and transfer lines
- Implement low dissolved oxygen (DO) brewing techniques, aiming for <50 ppb in packaged beer
What can I do with a beer with off-flavours
Some brewers choose to punish themselves for these off-flavours by making them consume the whole batch. Most others will cut their losses, dump the batch, and focus on adding some steps to ensure the off flavour doesn't occur again.
But there are a couple of other options depending on the off flavour:
Distillation:
If home distillation is legal in your region, then reflux distillation is a viable way to remove the alcohol from the affected batch for most of the off flavours except for sourness. This high percentage alcohol can then be used for a range of products.
Mixed culture:
Acetyl aldehyde and diacetyl are traditional products in alcohol production, and many yeasts and bacteria are able to metabolise these into more palatable flavours. Lactic and small amounts of acetic flavours are suitable for some beer styles. Hence, you will find in many forums that the suggestion is to add a mixed culture to the beer and forget about the beer for a year, and the result may be a pleasant beer.
By understanding the chemical processes behind these off-flavours and implementing these technical strategies, you'll be well-equipped to produce consistently high-quality homebrew. Remember, brewing is both an art and a science – embrace the technical aspects, and you'll be crafting world-class beer in no time.
MYO Drinks
Helping you to make your own Great Batch from Scratch.